There's nothing quite like a brand new aquarium; one filled with promise and potential. In the botanical-style aquarium, the aquarium looks quite a bit different than it will ultimately appear- the botanicals are clean and untouched by biofilms, the leaves appear crisp and largely intact, and the wood and substrate are typically sharp and free of that "patina" of growth that occurs over time.
Crisp. "Fresh." Clean-looking.
And that's nice, I suppose. I mean, it IS.
It meets the hobby's broadest "expectations" of just how an aquarium should look. At least, from a "neatness" standpoint, right? Many hobbyists- and I"m convinced, many more- would embrace the botanical-style aquarium more wholeheartedly if they could keep their systems sort of "frozen" in time at that point.
Yet, to many of us, the real "allure" of the botanical-style aquarium is what takes place after those first glistening weeks- the time period when the aquarium starts to evolve, take on an even more natural look, and becomes more of an ecosystem, as opposed to a primarily aesthetic display.
Of course, there are lots of ways to manage the establishment, "evolution" and long-term function of the botanical-style aquarium. You could regularly clean, remove, and replace all of your botanicals and leaves as they start to acquire that patina of biofilm, soften, and decompose. You could brush off all the biofilms, stir up and siphon the substrate, and literally "freeze" the aquarium in that "fresh-from-the-showroom" phase!
There is a sort of happy medium, of course.
You can retain much of the "baseline" look by leaving the bulk of the botanicals in place, perhaps removing/replacing a few selected pieces from time to time. This gives you a sort of "established" look, and doesn't remove all of the "function", offering you a manageable option to keeping your aquarium more-or-less "fresh.
Or, you can simply allow much of the material to remain in play, and add new pieces as you see fit. A sort of actively-managed "evolutionary" process. One that not only mimics Nature in many respects (I mean, leaves and seed pods and stuff are constantly falling into, or being swept by currents into, aquatic habitats, right?), it will keep the microorganism/fungal/microcrustacean population aquarium biologically "fueled up", with a continuous supply of new food sources...just like in Nature!
The continuous replacement and supplementation of leaves and botanicals as they start to break down is a sort of process- okay, maybe even a habit- which many of us who play with botanical-style aquariums. This not only creates a continuously evolving aesthetic, it helps maintain the biological diversity and environmental parameters are held in the cherished "tight range".
Variation on a theme: I know a few "tinters" who make significant replacements of leaf and botanical items, taking out a lot of the older materials, while replace them with fresh materials simultaneously, and this is conducted on a regular, although infrequent basis. This is similar to the Japanese aquascaping practice of "sozo haishoku" espoused by Takashi Amano, which is the processs of removing of as much old substrate material as possible along with the plants it contains in an aquarium, and replacing them with new materials.
It preserves the overall "composition" of the layout, but the "softscape" (the botanicals and leaves, in our case) could change dramatically over time.
This process is very interesting to us as botanical-style aquarium fans, because, as we talked about many times before, it does sort of mimic what happens in many streams and rivers on a seasonal basis: Older materials are swept downstream as the watercourses swell, and are replaced by new ones that arrive to replace them.
And of course, in the aquarium, performing a "sozo haishoku"-type replacement of materials can significantly change the aesthetic of the aquascape because the botanicals are replaced with different ones after the previous ones are removed. It essentially means that your aquarium will significantly change over extended periods of time, likely bringing a very different look to the tank at different points in its operating "life cycle."
On the "downside" (there's always one, right?), it can also create significantly different environmental parameters when we do big "change-ups" of materials in a short span of time; the impacts on our fishes may be positive or negative, depending upon the conditions which existed prior to the move.
Now, personally- I'm a fan of less "radical" moves, and in the interest of a good "offense", I favor regular, more measured additions to the botanical "set" in my aquariums. I tend not to remove any decomposing botanical material, unless it becomes an aesthetic detraction because it's blowing all over the place or something like that.
I while back, I did a slight "makeover" to my brackish water mangrove tank in my home office, which has accumulated a significant amount of decomposing mangrove leaf litter over the year it has been in operation. I wanted to add a lighter-colored, fine sandy substrate to be more consistent with some of the brackish-water Mangrove habitats I've studied. So what did I do? Well, I literally placed the sand on top of the accumulated leaf litter detritus...
A pretty radical move for me!
And really, what happens is that, through the power of the current and the activities of my fishes, some of it rises up to the surface once again! And the water parameters have been unaffected by this move. With the understanding that we are attempting to foster multiple "levels" of life forms in our tanks, NOT removing all of the decomposing materials is a good move, IMHO.
That was my "closest approach" to the process of "sozo haishoku", I think!
Think about food chains, microbial growth, and environmental stability in our aquariums. Fostering these requires us to embrace, rather than fear- some of these processes as they happen in our tanks.
And of course, Nature provides examples of similar processes.
Of course, I have no illusions that open, natural aquatic systems operate differently from our aquariums, but the "concept" is essentially the same... Study this pic by our friend, Tai Strietman taken in the Amazon...Leaves being covered by sand...interesting! Nature provides a "prototype" for everything, huh?
Having studied many images of Amazonian igarapes, it is very obvious that, although some materials are swept away by currents, etc., many do remain in place until they fully decompose, adding to the richness and complexity of the habitat, and that we can mimic this process in our aquariums to some advantage.
And, when coupled with good husbandry technique (ie; water exchanges, population management, feeding, and use/replacement of chemical filtration media) an eye for aesthetics, patience, and a focus on creating as complete-functioning a microcosm as possible in our tanks, long-term success is virtually a given in botanical-style aquariums.
Okay, emphasis on "virtually." Nothing is a complete "given" in this hobby!
Now, far be it from me to say that one of these systems won't test your patience, diligence, and perseverance- but to those who do endure and hold steady, the rewards are there. Facing, accepting, and dealing with some of the early "aesthetic challenges" in botanical-style aquariums, like the appearance and proliferation of biofilms, fungal growth, and the breakdown of botanicals is a fundamental step in building our "skill set" in this speciality.
A mental shift.
And of course, you can take radically different starting approaches, as I've done recently- creating aquariums which "look" established right from the start, because you're immediately utilizing materials which foster rapid growth of biofilms, decompose quickly, and develop fungal/microbial populations more rapidly.
I have found this process, utilizing different combinations of soils and sediments, mixes of highly ephemeral and durable botanical materials, and a variety of wood and roots, to create some fascinating microcosms which mimic the wild aquatic habitats we love in a surprisingly realistic and highly functional manner.
As every botanical-style aquarist knows, it's simply a fact that terrestrial materials, which exposed to water, will decompose, recruit fungal and biofilm growths, and substantially impact the aquatic environment and the physical appearance of our tanks.
Exactly like in Nature!
There is tremendous beauty in the ephemeral nature of aquatic habitats. At every phase of their existence, they are productive, beneficial, and appropriate for the various life forms which inhabit them.
It's no different in the aquarium. Stuff get's covered in biofilms. It begins to break down. Its appearance changes, and the aquarium habitat evolves. We need to embrace this process, understand it...Hell, we need to celebrate it! We don't always have to continuously "edit" the process. And how we manage this stuff, both mentally and practically, will impact the state of the art of truly "natural" aquariums for years to come.
There is more to these types of aquariums than just aesthetics.
There is the function. The evolution. The processes.
For decades, the hobby focus has been all about removing pretty much everything from aquairums as soon as it breaks down. I beg us to reconsider this long-held belief, and to think about the potential benefits of leaving materials in the tank to break down in situ.
The benefits, as we've talked about many times, are numerous- ranging from environmental consistency to continuous production of supplemental food sources for our fishes. An un-interrupted chain of life fostered in the botanical-style aquarium can yield amazing results.
We just have to give it the chance to "find its way..."
So, if you're tempted to remove all of the decomposing leaves or broken-down botanicals to preserve some aesthetic you have in your head...think twice, okay?
Preserve some of the old materials. Mix in some new ones. Re-distribute existing materials.
Think about the long-term impacts of such short term moves. Do think about the ability of the life-forms in our tank to process and utilize these materials if left undisturbed. Yes, consider the concept of "Sozo Haishoku", the transient nature of botanicals, and the evolution of your aquarium over time.
You might change the entire course of your aquarium- and you will almost certainly change the entire course of the hobby as a whole.
Stay observant. Stay curious. Stay diligent. Stay consistent. Stay thoughtful. Stay engaged...
And Stay Wet.